Sunday, 15 May 2016

Eye in the Sky (dir. Gavin Hood, 2016): A modern Iphigenia


Greek tragedy often sets a up a moral problem in which the interests of the oikos - the household, i.e. the family and family unit - are at odds with the interests of the polis - the city, i.e. the political state. In some cases, we as a modern audience can understand the dilemma - surely Antigone, for example, should be allowed to bury her traitor brother? And yet, we understand that Creon is tenuously holding on to hard-won power and nervous of any sign of frailty.

In other cases, however, we might find it difficult to see the choice as a real choice. When the goddess Artemis demands that Agamemnon sacrifice his young daughter, Iphigenia, so that the Greek army can get the right winds to sail for Troy (for an aggressive attack supposedly intended to retrieve his sister-in-law), it can be hard for a modern audience to sympathise. How could we ever consider killing a young girl in the hope of gaining a better wind?

At least since the publication of Jonathan Shay's excellent Achilles in Vietnam if not before, though, a number of scholars have been working on interpretations of Greek myth as stories which allowed the Greeks to deal with real traumas in a metaphorical way, much like the best science fiction and fantasy does in the modern world. A myth about a hero who is driven mad by a goddess and attacks his family, for example, may be an expression of very real incidences of post-traumatic stress disorder experienced, though of course not diagnosed, by returning Greek soldiers. In myth, the gods are the cause of the trouble, but these divine figures may be metaphors for more human causes.

The sacrifice of Iphigenia does not bear any particular relation to post-traumatic stress disorder, but it may reflect real experiences of Greek soldiers and the agonising decisions they have to make. We see almost the same decision, minus the personal connection, play out in Gavin Hood's excellent Eye in the Sky (which is also Alan Rickman's final on-screen performance, and a fitting swan song for a great actor). In this film, British and American forces face a dilemma - they have a chance to kill a group of dangerous terrorists, but doing so will almost certainly kill or severely maim an innocent little girl. What should they do?

Of course, in ancient Greece, drone warfare did not exist and this exact dilemma could not have happened. But enemy camps would not necessarily have been devoid of women and children, even in the ancient world. Camp followers would have been present, and some of them may have had children. Officers also sometimes brought their wives and children with them - in the Roman period, a group of mutineers were famously pacified when they frightened away the two-year-old Caligula and his mother. It is not inconceivable that an attack that would provide a strong tactical advantage would also kill or harm innocent children, and of course, any attack tended to result in the enslavement of the women and children on the losing side.

Agamemnon's specific dilemma (killing his own daughter) is unlikely to have occurred, just as the specific set of circumstances depicted in Eye in the Sky, while plausible, is fairly unlikely. But both Iphigenia and Eye in the Sky's Alia stand for all the young girls and boys killed or maimed, directly or indirectly, in warfare. The decision-making process in reality may not be so calculated or so personal, but any military attack, especially if it is anywhere near a civilian habitation, may bring with it innocent casualties, and those in the military must weigh up impossible decisions concerning the rights and wrongs of any such attack, decisions the rest of us hope never to have to face. That was a dilemma that affected the ancient Greeks just as much as it affects the modern military, and the fates of Iphigenia and Alia are a reminder of the true weight of those decisions.

8 comments:

  1. Excellent thoughts! The movie's playing in a rep theatre in my neighbourhood. I should catch it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. At least in the mythical story some could imagine that Iphigenia had not died under the knife, but had been replaced by a deer so that she could later be rescued by her brother. In our world we don't have the luxury of such thoughts. BTW, I have recently read "The Art of Intelligence" by Henry Crumpton (Penguin, 2012), the man who introduced drones into our warfare. He claims with a straight face that drones kill only the bad guys. Interesting book.

    ReplyDelete
  3. UFC 200 Jones vs Cormier 2 fight The UFC have confirmed a huge rematch between ufc 200 Jones vs Daniel Cormier that will be headlining the main card at UFC 200 live stream . The mega event is set to take place on July 9, 2016 at the T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas, Nevada. The main card will air on PPV after the preliminaries on UFC Fight.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Find a lawyer or law firm in Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia, Quebec, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland & Labrador, Northwest Territories, Nova

    canada lawyers list
    canadian lawyers
    canadian lawyers list

    ReplyDelete
  5. Professional beauty salon online in Skokie IL, Skokie, IL beauty and skin care salon. From facials, tinting, microdermabrasion, waxing and much more. beauty salon Skokie, IL beauty salon, skin care Skokie, skin care salon IL, professional beauty salon Skokie, Skokie professional beauty salon, Skokie skin care salon, facials Skokie, tinting Skokie, microdermabrasion Skokie, waxing Skokie, best beauty salon, best beauty salon Skokie, skin care specialist skokie. Click Below for more ...

    Beauty Salon Skokie
    Il Beauty Salon
    Skin Care Skokie
    Skin Care Salon Il
    Professional Beauty Salon Skokie
    Skin Care Specialist Skokie

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very nice post with quality content. Here is some information of my own blog. HCG Drops Diet Information and Where To Buy. HCG Drops are an easy way to take HCG, since their introduction they have quickly become the most popular way. Click Below for more ...

    hcg

    hcg drops

    hcg diet

    hcg diet drops

    ReplyDelete
  7. ufc 205 Alvarez vs McGregor PPV Fightheld on November 12, 2016 at Madison Square Garden in New York City, New York.watch ufc 205 live stream , how to watch ufc 205 live stream online,how to be buy ufc 205 PPV.

    ufc 205



    ufc 205 live



    ufc 205 fight pass 



    ufc 205 live stream ppv fight



    alvarez vs mcgregor



    ufc 205 fight start time



    ufc 205 fight card




    ReplyDelete

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...