Was Cleopatra beautiful and should we care?


I got into an interesting discussion on Twitter earlier which I thought I'd mention here rather than trying to work through complex issues in 140 characters or less!

Earlier today, I re-tweeted a link to an article from Heritage Daily on whether or not Cleopatra was beautiful. In response, I was asked 'But why is it relevant if she was beautiful or not?' We don't talk about whether or not Caesar and Mark Antony were incredibly handsome, so why are we talking about Cleopatra's looks? The whole thing is sexist because 'the beauty question is irrelevant.' (You can see some of the conversation here, if I've embedded the tweet correctly!)

On the one hand, yes, if what we are interested in is analysing and examining Cleopatra's role as a politician, her beauty (or lack thereof) is, indeed, largely irrelevant and focusing on it without mentioning Caesar and Antony's looks is sexist. I still think it's not quite as cut and dried as all that, since she cemented her political alliance with both of them by having a sexual relationship with both, plus according to Octavian's propaganda, Antony was madly in love with her - much as beauty is in the eye of the beholder and looks aren't everything, sexual attraction and romantic love are at least a little connected to looks. Plutarch tells us that what attracted Antony to Cleopatra romantically was her wit and intelligence and personality rather than her looks and I think that's genuinely interesting. But it is true that to focus on her looks but not on Caesar's or Antony's smacks of sexism.

That's not why the issue of Cleopatra's looks interests me, though. What interests me is the development of the tradition that she was beautiful. Cleopatra, in popular culture, is a stunner - she's Theda Bara, she's Claudette Colbert, she's Elizabeth Taylor (though Taylor's Cleopatra is political as well as beautiful). I, Claudius' Livia makes a reference to how she and one other 'in Egypt' were the most beautiful women in the world. In the popular imagination, Cleopatra is an exotic, sexual seductress, and beauty is a part of that.

However, like Caligula and Incitatus-as-consul, the ancient basis for this particular tradition is slim. (Suetonius, the old gossip, says Caligula thought about making Incitatus the horse consul - and now nearly every depiction of Caligula features a horse in the senate). In addition to Plutarch (who lived decades later) we have coins minted by Cleopatra and Antony that show her with fairly pointed features, a nice-looking woman but not stunningly beautiful. The tradition is, as far as we know, inaccurate.

The root of this tradition, presumably, lies in the idea that for Cleopatra to have ensnared both Caesar and Mark Antony, she must have been gorgeous. In a line of reasoning that is equally unfair to men and women, it has presumably been assumed that Caesar and Mark Antony had their otherwise politically savvy heads turned by a beautiful woman (because men only want one thing and only value women for their looks), and for this to happen, Cleopatra must have been gorgeous (because women are only capable of swaying men using sex, not through their intelligence or political ideas).

The reason I think the whole issue is interesting is precisely because we need to overturn this sort of sexist thinking. The popular view of Cleopatra, dominated by movies in which, of course, producers want to cast the most beautiful actress they can find, is of a woman who used her beauty to distract and detain two powerful men. The reality is much more complicated and more interesting - Cleopatra had political alliances with both men and she attracted them with her brains, not her beauty. I think the formation of the tradition, however sexist, is interesting, and I think the way to combat that sexism is to address the issue, look at the evidence, and ask whether the tradition conflicts with the ancient evidence and if so, why?

What do you think? Am I being sexist to think Cleopatra's beauty (or otherwise) is interesting?

Comments

  1. I think yes, her beauty was largely irrelevant: what really attracted Caesar and Mark Anthony was imho the simple fact that she was the queen of Egypt and viceversa: she would have hardly cared for them if they hadn't been the most powerful men of their era.
    By the way, I doubt a couple of centuries of inbreeding could do much to improve the looks of anyone ^^

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I think power comes first for all three of them!

      Delete
    2. Good point on the inbreeding! :p

      Delete
    3. Well, I was just reading an interesting article about the Habsburgs and Charles II of Spain, guess it wasn't very different for the Ptolemaioi back then.

      Delete
  2. Glad to see that my response resulted in a blog post! I basically agree with all you say. Like you, I am fascinated by the post-classical reception of Cleo. I have held quite a few public talks on the topic. But all have ended with someone asking the inevitable question: "But was Cleopatra beautiful?"
    And indeed, my twitter reaction was based on the fact that the article sets out to ask why Caesar and Antony fell for Cleopatra. To be fair, this particular author does give credit to her wit and charm, but still focuses on the forever-ongoing discussion on Cleopatra's attractive force, without even mentioning any political circumstances. The question that has lurked beneath since Antiquity is why these two powerful western men abandoned their true call, their political duties in Rome, to go sailing on the Nile or, even worse, turn into an orientalised half-man that fought Rome and lost. The answer has been reduced to Cleopatra's beauty, and, at times, also to her charm.
    It certainly seems as if Caesar and Antony enjoyed Cleopatra's company, but she too seems to have liked theirs. Hence the question could be turned around: Were Caesar and Antony good-looking, beautiful, sexy? Or what in their appearance made them attractive to the queen, a goddess in her country? Their wit? If those questions seem of less importance than the political prizes at stake (she got the throne back thanks to Caesar and increased her kingdom through him), then we should also put more political weight into Caesar and Antony's interest in Egypt and her queen. After all, Egypt abounded in riches and corn, it was situated very strategically close by the Asian provinces, and it was halfway to Parthia, India, and Alexander-like fame and world domination.
    That said, I do believe that individual charisma is a factor, and that individuals and their personal encounters can change the course of history. But far too much has been said of Cleopatra's looks and too little about the political benefits involved... although I do quite fancy Colin Wells comment about putting too much weight on politics and too little on romance: "Perhaps scholars cannot imagine themselves being carried away and sacrificing all for love, like Antony".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree! I'm sure in real life politics was the main reason, but of course Octavian's propaganda had people focused on the sex and not the politics very early on!

      Delete
  3. Allow me to quote at length from the new book, Antony And Cleopatra by Goldsworthy:

    “Absolutely nothing is certain. Cleopatra may have had black, brown, blonde or even red hair, and her eyes could have been brown, grey, green or blue. Almost any combination of these is possible. Similarly, she may have been very light skinned or had a darker more Mediterranean complexion. Fairer skin is probably marginally more likely given her ancestry. Greek art traditionally represented women and goddesses as very pale, and fair skin seems to have been part of the ideal of beauty. Roman propaganda never suggested that Cleopatra was dark-skinned, although this may simply mean that she was not exceptionally dark or simply that the color of her skin was not important to her critics.

    At no point will we need to consider Antony’s appearance at similar length and this should remind us that the obsession with Cleopatra’s looks is unusual, and not entirely healthy. Not only is there no good evidence, but also there is something disturbing about the desire to base our understanding of her first and foremost on her appearance. Cleopatra was not another Helen of Troy, a mythical figure about whom the most important thing was her beauty. She was no mere object of desire, but a very active political player in her own kingdom and beyond.

    Cleopatra was born and raised in the real and very dangerous world of the Ptolemaic court in the first century BC. When her father died in 51 BC, she became queen. Auletes had planned for his son and daughter to rule jointly. Cleopatra had other ideas.”
    -from Antony And Cleopatra by Adrian Goldsworthy, c2010 pp.128-129


    http://narukamisthunderbolts.blogspot.com/2010/11/cleopatra-obsession-with-beauty-antony.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There's a definite disconnect between the focus on Cleopatra's looks, but not on Antony or Caesar. (Though earlier my brother teased that wasn't I interested in the men's looks too and I mentioned that actually I am quite interested, though possibly not academically...!)

      Delete
    2. Power is what would have attracted Cleo, not looks. Same seems to work today too. Rich middle-aged men do not need to be lookers nor do powerful politions have problems finding sexual partners, looks aside. ;-)

      Delete
  4. Great post! Have you seen my Ugly Cleopatra blog? http://flavias.blogspot.co.uk/2011/09/ugly-cleopatra.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! I'm sure I have, I remember talking about this when I reviewed Beggar of Volubilis! Couldn't fit everything in though, as was in a hurry to get out this afternoon :)

      Delete
  5. I think it's a not entirely unreasonable question to ask, mostly because, as you note, Augustan propaganda tried very hard to make it look like Antony was being led around by his penis. (Of course, this then reflected poorly on Caesar, but then Augustus was never terribly careful about Caesar's reputation once he was safely deified.) Contemporaries describe her as not all that good-looking, frequently saying her nose was too big (take that, Asterix).

    The fact that no one asks if Antony was good-looking does introduce a bit of sexism to the question, I suppose, but this is largely a question of reception and the simple fact is that reception says she was beautiful. l would say that Caesar's appearance is well enough known that not asking it of him is within bounds. And anyone who's seen one of Antony's coins from his time in the east also has a ready answer: the man looked like what he was, an alcoholic gone badly to seed.

    Finally in regard to Cleo's looks, I am reminded of something Terry Pratchett once wrote to the effect that all princesses are, by definition, beautiful; saying otherwise is generally bad for your health. And of course, Cleopatra had something that overshadowed beauty, brains, and general sex appeal: Egypt. The wealthiest country in the known world and enough grain to feed the whole of Italy. But since Augustus had his own sights set on the place, he couldn't very well throw that at Antony. No, it had to be Oriental opulence and a woman's wiles.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wonder if, after Caesar was deified, he figured that sort of misbehaviour was par for the course for gods anyway! ;)

      Delete
  6. Power definitely comes first in the equation. Each of them had power, and the other saw advantages in that.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I don't have anything to add to the discussion, but I did want to say it's a very interesting topic Juliette! I for one never stopped to think about the question of Cleo's beauty, but two men like that I think would need more than just looks to sway them...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! :) It was Caroline's Beggar of Volubilis that first brought all this to my attention - I must admit, I think it's fascinating!

      Delete
  8. Love this post! I've posted a sort of response over on the Kateantiquity blog - do come visit if you have a moment! http://kateantiquity.com/2013/10/17/on-cleopatras-beauty/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Being a vampire is not what it seems like. It’s a life full of good, and amazing things. We are as human as you are.. It’s not what you are that counts, but how you choose to be. Do you want a life full of interesting things? Do you want to have power and influence over others? To be charming and desirable? To have wealth, health, and longevity? contact the vampires creed today via email: Richvampirekindom@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  10. hi,
    Freelance IP Network Engineer
    IP networks must function in a stable and reliable manner, and that is where IP network engineers intervene. They can maintain the network, as well as supervise the work, such as updating and modifying the IP network, since it needs to grow and expand over time.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I work as a marketing specialist and staff author at Externetworks which is a pioneer in Managed Technology Services with over 17+ years of experience in providing end-to-end solutions featuring design, deployment and 24*7 support to top IT companies. We offer world-class managed services for businesses to stay agile & profitable. Our services include 24/7 Network Monitoring, Uptime maintenance, NOC Support, IT Helpdesk services.

    To know about Managed IT Services for Healthcare

    ReplyDelete
  12. Vegus168 คาสิโน ออนไลน์ Watch football online. Online football betting
    Only one account you need for access to all kinds of online betting
    football betting, online casino, baccarat, roulette, dragon-tiger and slot games
    Watch your favorite football team in action
    Get excited with football betting
    Make money online at your home or anywhere

    ReplyDelete
  13. Really! Nice blog, thanks for sharing this great content online, i read your content carefully and got clear understanding about "Men's Hockey", i hope other reader also love to read your content and share positive feedback. Thanks

    Reach out here:
    Electrician near me
    Electrician Arizona
    Electrical repair
    Electrical Contractor Az

    ReplyDelete
  14. Find the steps to download, install and activate the Norton product.

    NORTON.COM/SETUP
    NORTON.COM/SETUP
    NORTON.COM/SETUP

    ReplyDelete
  15. Visit to create your Webrootaccount. Install Webroot on your device from webroot.com/safe to remove viruses and bugs
    webroot.com/safe

    ReplyDelete
  16. Managed Fiber servicesWithout a good internet connection and a reliable Managed Fiber Service, your business does not have wings to fly or the capacity for growth.

    ReplyDelete
  17. 928bet สมัครสมาชิก คาสิโนออนไลน์ เว็บไซต์ เดิมพันอันดับหนึ่ง ฝาก-ถอนเงิน อัตโนมัติ

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thanks for sharing a great article.
    You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
    Keep posting like this informative articles.
    Thank you.

    Get to know about ms office 2010

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for sharing a great article.
    You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
    Keep posting like this informative articles.
    Thank you.

    Get to know about facebook

    ReplyDelete
  20. 928bet เเทงบอล คาสิโนออนไลน์ เครดิตฟรี 100บาท เปิดบริการตลอด24ชั่วโมง เดิมพันสุดสนุกไปกับเรา

    ReplyDelete
  21. mgwin88 สมัครสมาชิก คาสิโนออนไลน์ เปิดบริการ 24ชั่วโมง ฝาก-ถอนเงิน รวดเร็ว

    ReplyDelete
  22. Are you searching for assignment help in the UAE? Then don’t worry! We provide you the best assignment writing services at very cheap prices. Visit our website for help with your work.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Our Homework Help writers have experience in writing assignments for students across the United States and understand the necessities of the professors. This way, we guarantee that you will get the best marks by submitting other assignments without any hassle. So get ready to improve your overall results with our exclusive writing services in the United States. Also, look out for our additional deals and discounts that we mention on our website.

    Read More : https://bit.ly/3cmVKXm

    ReplyDelete
  24. LogisticGuru.PVT the best Car Transport In Shimla are not only providing you with the best car moving or cars shifting service but also promising you to keep your precious vehicle safely. Suppose you are moving from one place to another and having a lot of stuff to relocate. In such a situation, it becomes quite difficult to drive your car on your own. So you need someone like LogisticGuru.PVT who can take care of your vehicle and relocate it along with your stuff.

    Visit us : https://bit.ly/359xUKF

    ReplyDelete
  25. Cash App is the easiest way to send, spend, save, and invest your money. It's the SAFE, FAST, and FREE mobile banking app. First of all, you need to install Cash App on your mobile. Tap on the “Sign In” tab. Fill up your login details.
    Cash app login | Cash App Login

    ReplyDelete
  26. If you are looking for the assignment help check all the details of the assignment help for me here.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Opt for our Assignment Help to finish your assignments and submit them within the deadline. No need to take the stress of insufficient knowledge and lack of skills when you have an online assignment writing expert for writing your assignment in Qatar.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Why are you getting tense about tech services? I know the best and reliable service for the RR email which will be a good fit for your requirements. I have also used their service many times and I can tell you that they are amazing with their work. Their service is super fast and user friendly. You must visit their Roadrunner email Support website.

    Visit their Blog on Roadrunner email problems to get the details.

    Dial our Roadrunner email support number to solve all your Roadrunner email problems.
    Also, if you want help regarding Microsoft office, then visit our Microsoft Office 365 Support website and get to know in detail.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Tips is another great feature that you will get with idm crack. It will let you know all the secret features of IDM. Whenever you will open it. At that time it will let you know one thing about it. Using this you can learn everything about it. Also, if you don’t want it on the startup then you can easily disable it.

    ReplyDelete
  30. https://customboxesbulk.com/ are here to solve all your problems regarding custom boxes wholesale. As it is the priority of Custom boxes bulk to assist its clients to the extreme level.

    ReplyDelete
  31. you'll get our printed custom boxes wholesale whether you're a businessman. or a daily individual who wants these Custom boxes for fulfilling custom packaging boxes needs.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Aamanns nytænkte form af klassisk smørrebrød er en oplevelse. Vi bestilte "Lidt af hvert" og det viste sig at være et godt valg. take away amager Man kommer rundt om det meste og vi var mætte og veltilfredse da vi forlod etablisemenet..

    ReplyDelete
  33. Now that we've looked at a few of the numerous advantages of hiring professional resume writers rather than scrounging a CV off of Linkedin, let's have a look at three of the best current resume writing services available to you. So find best resume services online here

    ReplyDelete
  34. At my assignment help , we work as per the understudies. Here, we have a straightforward method to get a PhD task help administration by experts. You can drop us your requirements and our group will return you with the comprehension of the subject that you have given. After your affirmation and installment, our group will begin chipping away at the task.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Great deals of important information and also a great article. I am currently following for your blog site and I am bookmarking it for future reference. Many thanks for sharing

    best Point of Sale Software in India

    ReplyDelete
  36. check out the assignment answers online here. You will find answers of all your assignment from our side. You can also post your own questions for your answer’s assistance. We will help you out as best we can.

    ReplyDelete
  37. This is the best way to jot down information having exact detail. In case you want to some experts help to check your papers, contact sourceessay.com based proof-readers team for online assignment help. uk cheap dissertation writing service Germany

    ReplyDelete

  38. Hi,

    Really great article!!

    Also read about when looking to finance higher education main funding sources for higher education are Federal Students Loans, Private Loans, and scholarships.







    ReplyDelete
  39. If you are looking for Online Grocery Shopping Durgapur, download Bazaar Durgapur App from Playstore. Order Now and get exclusive discounts on combo offers!

    ReplyDelete
  40. If you are looking for best MOBILE APP DEVELOPMENT company then you should think about Actovision. A company having whole lot of experience on app development. Get a quote now!

    ReplyDelete
  41. We are a top rated CHCDIS007 Assessment Answers Online service here with experts specializing in a wide range of disciplines ensuring you get the assignments that score maximum grades.

    ReplyDelete


  42. Creating Quality Brand Image The great quality custom boxes with logo packaging allows the businesses to develop a brand that is worthy, reliable, and can be perceived in the trustworthy manner possible.

    ReplyDelete

  43. Global Liver Health Supplements Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the global Liver Health Supplements Market, assessing the market based on its segments like products, dosage forms, distribution channels, types, and major regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. It also assesses the market dynamics, covering the key demand and price indicators, along with analyzing the market based on the SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces models. This is, thus, propelling the market growth of liver supplements. The easy availability of liver health supplements from an extensive distribution channel is also fuelling the growth of the market. The rising dependency on internet services and the booming e-commerce industry are further providing impetus to the growth of the market.





    If you wish to see more reports check here: Asia Pacific Vaccine Market, Micro Inverter Market, Albumin Market, Middle East and Africa Cybersecurity Market,LiDAR Drone Market, Vegetable Concentrates Market, Learning Management System Market, States Flooring Market, Sports and Energy Drinks Market, Brazil Healthcare, Sterilisation Services Market, Media Monitoring Tools Market

    ReplyDelete
  44. Outstanding Quality All our works write my essay have one thing in common - the highest quality. We work hard to deliver you only the best papers.
    Outstanding Quality All our works write my essay have one thing in common - the highest quality. We work hard to deliver you only the best papers.
    Meeting Deadlines

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment